02/08/05 13:23 Filed by Saswat Pattanayak in:
Saswat | Editorial
By Saswat Pattanayak
Histories can be telling. Especially
when they are told by the mainstream American media.
The country of concentrated wealth also has the
knowledge distribution centralized and no wonder from
John Stewart to Michael Moore, the public humorists
often cite how many Americans think Canada is another
Hawaii (but now since they are required to carry
passports to Niagara Falls, some among them have
started believing Canada is a separate country)!
Indeed, in a recent chat conversation, a woman from
California asked me where I was chatting from?
“Maryland”, I said. “You are funny. Mary-land? Ok
now, tell me which state?” She of course took offence
when I asked if she knew where Washington DC was. She
knew where DC was….so ok, now gotcha.
Next incident may sound even more incredible. While
buying fresh fish at Whole Foods in Silver Spring,
our man at the counter asked me, “So are you from
Argentina?” No, I said. I am from India. “Yeah but
where are you originally from?” I wondered about
that, since from experience I knew it’s difficult for
some Americans to believe “immigrant-looking” people
to be Americans. Hence I did not say him that I was
from a nearby city called Adelphi, but that I had
actually come from India to do the shopping. “You
know although I stay in Maryland, I am originally
from India,” I reiterated. He was not buying that.
“Oh, Indiana! You look so much different”. No, not
Indiana. I am from India—India as in a country. In
Asia. India—the computers, the elephants.
He was looking at me puzzled. He had never heard of
India (luckily, he had heard of Indiana State.) I was
accompanied by my office boss. She did not believe
this. “Where has he been hiding all these years, for
not to know about India?” I nodded.
Often times one encounters ignorance of mass
proportions in the country of concentrated wealth.
People still believe that Columbus actually
discovered America, that Russians were a bunch of
murderers out there to kill every American and that
Bush did not lie about Iraq and the WMD.
This week, yet another of the great lies have been
incorporated by the most read, most cited mainstream
media. Another leaf from the American
history-telling. In the next blog.
Tags: Saswat, Media, Immigrant, USA, Racism